And where the hell is the undercurrent? Meanwhile, Yanqui U. Ideas are scarce, too-- where Skinny Fists would erupt without warning into a scorching Satriani-esque solo "Cancer Towers on Holy Road Hi-Way" , the tracks on Yanqui are content to continue building to bored, satiated endings we can see coming 20 minutes in advance. Couldn't we have some venting? Are we frustrated or just dramatic?
Worse: The record is consumed by a painfully glacial pace. It doesn't. Once, at the end of "Rockets Fall on Rocket Falls," the band comes close with a triumphant burst of cinematic melody and Efrim's wailing screwdriver'd guitar.
The quarter-hour denouement that precedes it is a long road to travel, though, and with this record's production difficulties, you're slogging through the mud every step of the way. See, the importance of strong production on a record like this cannot be exaggerated, and I place much of the blame for Yanqui failure to impact on Steve Albini's shoulders.
Last year, he turned Mogwai's similar-minded My Father, My King into a raging, five-headed superbeast with precision micing and mixing that brought the music's strongest elements to the fore, resulting in a speaker-rattling detonation of pristine strength. Yanqui is no recreation, or even approximation, of that tunneling force.
Here, perhaps because of the number of instruments at hand, or maybe because of the insane over-reverbing, all of the instruments save the ever-present martial drums blend together into a kind of murky concordance, often making distinguishing the guitars from the violins an impossibility.
What we're left with, then, is the skeleton of an incredibly original band whose once-driving conviction and determination has been sapped by sluggishness and a lack of invention. It doesn't help that they've spawned countless imitators and saturated the market with uniform side projects.
The second, much shorter, features echoing feedback and softly picked guitars; if anything, it is even more desperately melancholy than the first. If Rockets Fall on Rocket Falls runs the risk of pomposity - clocking in at over 20 minutes, its final crescendo is rather too drawn-out and ponderous for its own good - it nevertheless contains some startling moments, where its hushed brass and clarinet interludes slowly grow into the kind of disorientated guitar rock that My Bloody Valentine pioneered.
The closing two parts of Motherfucker Redeemer are weirdly funky. The first features something roughly analogous to a disco beat, topped off with a bassline that owes debts to the earlys Krautrock of Neu! The second, meanwhile, offers breathtaking drumming that appears to fly off in several directions at once GYBE feature two percussionists , and a gorgeous, impenetrable wall of guitars and strings.
Godspeed You! Black Emperor's sound is frequently aligned to the post-rock movement of the mids. As the name suggests, that genre attempted to move past the standard cliches of guitar rock, taking on board influences from techno to jazz. Unfortunately, where it moved to was rather arid and bloodless. Like a lot of instrumental music, post-rock wound up sounding like an unappealing intellectual exercise. One of the many things that is remarkable about Yanqui UXO is how unlike post-rock it seems.
For the most part, the five tracks keep the listener's attention over their inordinate length because they sound human and passionate: the melodies are engaging, the band are audibly playing for their lives. In that respect, Godspeed You! Black Emperor are far less pretentious than their attendant publicity suggests. Alexis Petridis. More pop CD reviews Instrumental rock is a curious beast.
The Guardian. Archived from the original on November 7, Retrieved July 9, Archived from the original on April 19, Retrieved August 5, Black Emperor — Yanqui U.
Drowned in Sound. Retrieved June 10, December Stylus Magazine. Archived from the original on February 1, Authority control MBRG : fc3cf08cafed-aba Black Emperor albums Instrumental rock albums.
Hidden categories: Use mdy dates from October Articles with short description Short description is different from Wikidata Articles with hAudio microformats Articles containing Spanish-language text Track listings with input errors Wikipedia articles with MusicBrainz release group identifiers. Namespaces Article Talk.